RESTRUCTURING WILL STREAMLINE APC OPERATION
Jonathan Gardner
April 25, 1994
WASHINGTON - The American Plastics Council will get its own president
and eliminate a panel consisting of the managers of the chemical companies'
resin businesses under a restructuring plan approved by APC's board
of directors. The restructuring accomplishes some of the aims of an
earlier plan to merge APC into the Chemical Manufacturers Association.
But a top APC board official played down that result, portraying
it as a streamlining move. And two processors contacted last week
said they recognize the need to streamline some communications and
implementation functions.
The new hierarchy calls for the APC's new president and chief executive
officer to report directly to the board of directors, rather than
through Larry Thomas, president of the Society of the Plastics Industry
Inc., and the sub-board coordinating group made up of resin company
managers.
APC's current top official, Group Vice President Donald Shea, will
be a candidate for the new CEO job, but the board will search for
other candidates.
Earnest Deavenport, the Eastman Chemical Co. chairman and CEO who
now is APC's board chairman, argued that the top-level moves do
not mean APC is severing its relationship with SPI.
Rather, Deavenport said in a telephone interview from his home
in Kingsport, Tenn., the plan will ``continue APC as a joint venture
with SPI, including SPI representatives on the executive committee
and board,'' while maintaining the APC board's status as one of
a number of special-issue CMA panels called Chemstar councils.
``It will be a much cleaner and much more direct structure,'' Deavenport
said.
APC's board of directors approved the plan at an April 20 meeting
in Naples, Fla. The plan will take effect after the board's June
8 meeting, the final meeting of the 1993-94 fiscal year.
It followed weeks of turmoil within SPI's membership. Some processor
members in early February learned of an impending decision to change
the organization's structure through a letter sent by an SPI staff
member that portrayed the APC board's high-level moves as a divorce
of APC from SPI.
That letter urged SPI processor members to lobby their resin suppliers
against such a move.
Objections from processors reportedly stalled such a direct departure.
But some SPI insiders say the latest APC board decisions effectively
remove SPI oversight from APC, a group with a $50 million budget
that aimed to allay consumers' concerns about plastics' impact on
the environment.
Under the restructuring, the chemical companies' resin business
managers who sat on the sub-board coordinating group will have seats
on the board of directors. The board's membership now consists primarily
of the chemical company chief executives to whom the plastics managers
report.
However, each of APC's 25 member companies still will have only
one vote on the board.
Some insiders questioned whether the senior plastics executives
will have any authority at all because the CEOs to whom they report
also will be on the board. In addition, some said the one-vote-per-company
rule will tend to dilute the resin managers' authority.
But Deavenport said elevating the resin business managers to board
level increases their ability to participate in decision-making.
``If anything it's a much more participatory-type board structure
than we have had with the hierarchy of the board and the coordinating
group,'' Deavenport said. ``We will have more interlocking relationships
on our board and committees.''
Two processors reached last week said elimination of the coordinating
group may be a good idea.
``That's probably a wise thing for them to do,'' said Harry Ussery,
vice chairman of SPI's Plastics Mobilization Committee and president
of Beacon Plastics Inc. of Greenville, S.C. ``It seemed to be a
redundant step.''
But Ussery, an SPI board member, said he wants to see full details
of the restructuring before he makes any final judgments.
George Makrauer, the president of bag
maker Amko Plastics Inc. in Cincinnati and early advocate of creating
APC, agreed that such a move will remove ``bureaucratic impediments.''
``My sense is that bringing these business
managers into a direct operating relationship with their CEOs will
benefit the program for two reasons,'' Makrauer said. ``First, the
respective CEOs respect and listen to their operations people, and
second, the operations people are much closer to these industry
pressures that were the reason APC was formed.''
Elevating the working committees, which now sit below the coordinating
group, Thomas and Shea, also will improve communications and program
implementation, according to Deavenport.
One of those committees, the Industry Mobilization Committee, is
staffed by SPI employees and depends on SPI's processor members
for success.
Makrauer
said the new APC president will have a great influence over how
well the group represents and involves processors.
``I think it is essential that this intimate
relationship with SPI be maintained,'' Makrauer said. ``I hope that
the individual selected as CEO is impressed with that aspect of
the relationship because, from the processors' standpoint, we see
our link to this challenge to the industry as being with SPI through
APC,'' he said.
The elimination of the coordinating group, which Deavenport portrayed
as a move to improve communication and program implementation, also
holds implications for SPI's influence over APC.
The coordinating group consisted typically of the resin business
managers, many of whom have close ties to the processor members
of SPI.
And APC's operating committees-including the Industry Mobilization
Committee, which draws heavily from SPI's membership-will be directly
under the authority of the board, rather than the coordinating group.
In theory, Shea reported to Thomas, who in turn reported to the
APC coordinating group. Thomas also sat on the APC board of directors.
But according to some SPI insiders, Thomas only attempted to exercise
that authority briefly after APC's formation in late 1991 and early
1992 by having SPI staff members sit in on APC meetings.
Thomas was instructed to back off and allow APC's staff to operate
independently.
Thomas still had some power over APC staff members' pay and compensation,
as they were on SPI's payroll.
But according to some insiders, the latest move will eliminate
that oversight and will foster even more independence in APC's staff.
The two staffs are in adjoining offices and share telephone services.
APC's staff grew out of an SPI project called the Council for Solid
Waste Solutions. Still, according to insiders, the staff cultures
of APC and SPI clash.