BREAKING DOWN GREENPEACE SCAM
June 01, 1998
On March 14, 1990, in Washington, Greenpeace held a press conference
to announce and introduce its report called ``Breaking Down the Degradable
Plastics Scam.'' The room was filled with over 60 news reporters and
nine videographers from general, environmental and business news organizations.
Also attending were five representatives of the Degradable Plastics
(now Polymers) Council, part of the Society of the Plastics Industry
Inc.
Socialist erstwhile ``educator'' and Greenpeace hack Barry Commoner
led the plastics-bashing. It halted when one audience member asked
him, ``Mr. Commoner, isn't this really just a simple dispute between
the paper bag industry and the plastic bag industry, and isn't what
really bothers you is the fact that consumers have shown an increasing
preference for plastic bags because they're stronger, waterproof,
less expensive and more convenient to --''
At that point, Greenpeace moderator Michael Rappoport circled his
arm high in the air and brought it down with a flourish. ``Sir,''
he derisively shouted. ``If you're here as a representative of the
plastics industry, we'd appreciate your paying for one-half the
rental of this room. Next question!''
A quiet hush filled the room. The next question was asked. As Commoner
was answering, a Greenpeace staffer slid to the stage and slipped
a note to Rappoport at the podium. Tension filled Rappoport's visage.
At the close of Commoner's answer, Rappoport looked back at his
rudely squelched prior questioner and said, ``Mr. Handelsman,
it's
been brought to my attention that you're not a member of the plastics
industry but, in fact, a member of the news media. What I said
before
was inappropriate, and I apologize. Would you like to ask your
question again?''
Ladies and gentlemen: Meet Steve Handelsman, then pool reporter
for NBC-affiliated stations. Oops. A noisy hush filled the room,
as he asked his question again.
Flustered, Commoner fumbled his way through a reply that concluded
with an assertion that his solution to the environmental problem
of plastic bags was to put handles onto paper bags.
Shortly thereafter, the conference crumbled to an end. The facts
about Greenpeace's motives and intentions, well-known to some, had
become obvious to all. For the next 1-1/2 hours, Degradable Plastics
Council representatives answered questions from eight of the nine
video news crews, and only CNN Headline News ran any story at all
about the Greenpeace report. No news outlet reported on the event,
the press conference, the embarrassment to Greenpeace and its self-discreditation.
In short, all the media missed the obvious story.
Giving some of the media representatives a bit more credit for
cognizance but not for integrity, those who got the story ignored
the news. The "scam'' then was the Greenpeace report. The scam
today is the Greenpeace "biodegradable credit card.''
The plastics industry still has no one to report the facts but
itself. Plastics News' May 18 editorial about the news media "succumbing
to sloppy reporting'' is right on target. It's also a fact that
the plastics industry remains at the center of the bull's-eye.
George A. Makrauer
ComAd Management Group Inc.
Treasure Island, Fla.